Who Should Join the Next Season of The Traitors?
Season 3 of The Traitors was a wild ride filled with backstabbing, mind games, and unforgettable moments—including Tom Sandoval’s off-key singing challenge. As the season wraps up, fans are already buzzing about potential contestants for Season 4.
With Alan Cumming’s castle awaiting a fresh batch of players, it’s time to compile the ultimate dream cast list. These reality TV stars have the charisma, strategic prowess, and entertainment factor needed to make Season 4 an even bigger hit.
Let’s dive into the dream picks!
Paige DeSorbo (Summer House)
Why She’d Be Perfect
Paige DeSorbo, a fan-favorite from Summer House, has all the makings of a Traitors star. As the co-host of The Giggly Squad podcast, she’s well-versed in reality TV drama and sharp-witted commentary.
Her ability to read people and detect deception would make her an excellent Faithful. Paige wouldn’t be easily swayed by smooth-talking Traitors, and her social game would allow her to form strong alliances.
How She’d Play the Game
- Strengths: Strategic, highly observant, and socially adept.
- Potential Role: A strong Faithful with a keen eye for deception.
- Wildcard Factor: Her iconic fashion choices would steal the show, making her the best-dressed contestant in Traitors history.
Photo Credit: Euan Cherry/Peacock via Getty Images
Why He’d Be Perfect
Nick Viall has spent years dissecting reality TV relationships on The Viall Files, making him an expert in reading people. As a former Bachelor lead, he knows how to charm, persuade, and manipulate—perfect skills for navigating The Traitors’ mind games.
How He’d Play the Game
- Strengths: Excellent conversationalist and manipulator.
- Potential Role: A convincing Faithful who could rally others—or a Traitor with a masterful social game.
- Wildcard Factor: His deep knowledge of reality TV strategy might either help him go far or make him an immediate target.
JaNa Craig (Love Island USA)
Why She’d Be Perfect
JaNa Craig’s ability to form fast and strong relationships made her a fan favorite on Love Island USA. In The Traitors, social skills are just as valuable as strategy, and JaNa would be a powerhouse in both departments.
How She’d Play the Game
- Strengths: Likable, socially intelligent, and quick-thinking.
- Potential Role: A Faithful with strong influence over the group—or a stealthy Traitor.
- Wildcard Factor: Her charm would make her a key decision-maker at roundtables, putting her in a position of power.
Andy Rueda (Survivor)
Why He’d Be Perfect
Andy Rueda played a fast-paced, high-risk game on Survivor, making him an ideal contestant for The Traitors. His ability to improvise and think on his feet would serve him well, whether as a Faithful or a Traitor.
How He’d Play the Game
- Strengths: Unpredictable, entertaining, and willing to take big risks.
- Potential Role: A chaotic Traitor who plays aggressively or a wildcard Faithful.
- Wildcard Factor: His bold strategies might make him a target early, but if he survives the first few rounds, he could dominate.
Gizelle Bryant (Real Housewives of Potomac)
Why She’d Be Perfect
Gizelle Bryant brings the drama wherever she goes. As a veteran Real Housewives star, she’s a master at confrontation and stirring the pot. While she might not have the best track record for spotting deception, she’d definitely make the roundtable discussions must-watch television.
How She’d Play the Game
- Strengths: Fearless, outspoken, and unafraid to call people out.
- Potential Role: A highly entertaining Faithful who adds chaos to the game.
- Wildcard Factor: Her shady one-liners would make her an instant fan favorite.
Will Kirby (Big Brother)
Why He’d Be Perfect
Will Kirby is a legend in the Big Brother world, known for his strategic mind and ability to manipulate. Though he has yet to officially play The Traitors, he previously hosted a challenge on Season 2, proving he has a keen interest in the show.
How He’d Play the Game
Strengths
Highly intelligent, persuasive, and cunning.
Potential Role
The ultimate Traitor—he could lie his way to the end.
Wildcard Factor
He might have a target on his back immediately due to his reputation, but if he survives the early game, he could dominate.
Rachel LaMont (Survivor 47)
Why She’d Be Perfect
Rachel LaMont played a flawless game on Survivor 47, proving she’s a strategic mastermind. Her ability to read people and make calculated moves would make her a dangerous Traitors player.
How She’d Play the Game
- Strengths: Analytical, adaptable, and highly strategic.
- Potential Role: A lethal Traitor who plays a long game—or a Faithful who leads the charge against deception.
- Wildcard Factor: She’d likely go far in the game, making her a major threat to both Faithfuls and Traitors alike.
Honorable Mentions
While the main cast picks above would make for an unforgettable season, there are plenty of other reality TV stars who would thrive in The Traitors. Here are a few more names to consider:
- Dan Gheesling (Big Brother) – One of the greatest strategists in reality TV history.
- CT Tamburello (The Challenge) – His competitive nature and social skills would be fascinating to watch.
- Tiffany Pollard (Flavor of Love, I Love New York) – A reality TV icon who would bring drama and humor.
- Shan Smith (Survivor 41) – A master of deception who could thrive as a Traitor.
- Bethenny Frankel (Real Housewives of New York) – Sharp-witted, strategic, and always in control of the room.
Final Thoughts: Who Will Join The Traitors Season 4?
With The Traitors gaining more popularity each season, the pressure is on for the casting team to deliver an all-star lineup. The ideal Season 4 cast should be a mix of strategists, social players, and drama-stirrers, creating a game full of suspense and unpredictability.
Fans can only hope that some of these dream picks will make their way into Alan Cumming’s castle. Until then, we’ll be eagerly awaiting Season 4 announcements.
Tell Us – Who’s on Your Traitors Dream Cast List?
Would you add any other reality stars to the mix? Share your picks for The Traitors Season 4 in the comments!
The Traitors is available to stream on Peacock.
- Elsbeth & Kaya’s Friendship Status in Season 2 Explained - April 1, 2025
- Full House Star/Convicted Felon Lori Loughlin Seeks $17.5 Million For Hidden Hills Mansion - April 1, 2025
- Love Is Blind Season 4 Netflix Release Date & Time - March 31, 2025
