A Match Made in Reality TV Heaven
The reality TV gods blessed us with two captivating competition shows in 2025: The Traitors Season 3 and Deal or No Deal Island (DONDI) Season 2. These shows had us on the edge of our seats, delivering drama, suspense, and unforgettable moments.
Hosted by Alan Cumming, The Traitors showcased jaw-dropping betrayals, cunning strategy, and shocking eliminations. In the end, four Faithfuls—Dolores Catania, Dylan Efron, Gabby Windey, and Lord Ivar Mountbatten—secured victory and split the prize pot.
Meanwhile, Deal or No Deal Island, hosted by Joe Manganiello, combined physical endurance, social gameplay, and sheer luck as contestants battled for the grand prize. Reality TV icons like Big Brother’s Dr. Will Kirby, Survivor legend Parvati Shallow, and Australian Survivor winner David Genat competed in the high-stakes game.
As we look to the future, the question arises: which stars from The Traitors should test their skills on Deal or No Deal Island? Let’s explore our top picks.
Photo Credit: Euan Cherry/Peacock
Derrick Levasseur: A Master Strategist in Any Game
Derrick’s Reality TV Journey
Derrick Levasseur made a dramatic entrance into The Traitors alongside The Challenge’s Wes Bergmann and Survivor legend Boston Rob Mariano. Suspended in cages above the ground, the trio shocked the other contestants with their surprise arrival.
Derrick is widely recognized as one of the best Big Brother players of all time. He won Season 16 by forming key alliances and subtly influencing major game decisions. His ability to remain in control while avoiding the spotlight made him a formidable competitor.
Why Derrick Would Excel on DONDI
Derrick’s strategic prowess would make him a strong contender on Deal or No Deal Island. The game is full of twists, and players need to think quickly to adjust their approach. Derrick has already proven his adaptability, and his ability to read people would be invaluable when negotiating with the Banker.
Though Derrick was eliminated in The Traitors after accusing Boston Rob at the Round Table, his impressive gameplay solidified his reputation as a top-tier strategist. His mix of likability, intelligence, and calculated risk-taking would make him a must-watch player on DONDI.
Photo Credit: Euan Cherry/Peacock
Gabby Windey: A Charismatic and Underrated Competitor
Gabby’s Rise to Fame
Gabby Windey first gained public attention on The Bachelor and later became The Bachelorette. She further showcased her competitive spirit by finishing as the runner-up on Dancing with the Stars Season 31.
On The Traitors, Gabby aligned with Chrishell Stause and Nikki Garcia in the so-called “Bambi alliance.” While her game lacked an overarching strategy, she displayed keen observational skills. Gabby caught Traitor Danielle Reyes sneaking out of a secret room, an insight that would have major game implications.
Why Gabby Would Shine on DONDI
Gabby’s magnetic personality would make her an instant fan favorite on Deal or No Deal Island. While she isn’t known for cutthroat gameplay, she’s highly perceptive and emotionally intelligent.
However, Gabby’s ability to handle intense physical challenges remains a question mark. Would she thrive in grueling endurance tasks, or struggle with the more extreme elements of island life? Either way, watching Gabby balance her social charm with high-stakes decision-making would be TV gold.
Photo Credit: Euan Cherry/Peacock
Dylan Efron: The Ultimate Faithful Turned Island Contender
Dylan’s Journey on The Traitors
Dylan Efron, the younger brother of actor Zac Efron, built his own name as a travel influencer and YouTube personality. On The Traitors, he was the ultimate Faithful—always vigilant, always questioning.
Dylan was one of the first to suspect Bob the Drag Queen of being a Traitor, but his instincts weren’t enough to convince the group at the time. However, when Boston Rob made his move against Bob, Dylan was right by his side, proving his ability to adapt and work with shifting alliances.
Why Dylan Would Dominate DONDI
Dylan’s athleticism and adventurous nature make him a natural fit for Deal or No Deal Island. His experience traveling the world and tackling extreme environments suggests he’d have no problem with the island’s physical demands.
Moreover, Dylan has the social skills and competitive edge needed to excel in the game’s high-pressure negotiations. His likability ensures he’d be a strong social player, while his growing strategic awareness makes him an underrated pick for success.
Photo Credit: Euan Cherry/Peacock
Britney Haynes: A Sharp Mind and a Ruthless Competitor
Britney’s Reality TV Legacy
Britney Haynes became a fan favorite on Big Brother for her biting wit and strategic acumen. On The Traitors, she played a quiet yet deadly game, avoiding suspicion while making critical moves.
Boston Rob attempted to throw Britney under the bus when his back was against the wall, but she masterfully turned the tide against him. Later, she shocked the castle by betraying her closest ally, Danielle Reyes, in a stunning Round Table blindside.
Why Britney Would Be Perfect for DONDI
Britney is a thinker. She carefully plots her moves, assesses her competition, and strikes when the time is right. On Deal or No Deal Island, she would have the upper hand in making calculated choices and handling high-stakes negotiations.
Her ability to stay calm under pressure is another major asset. When dealing with the Banker, players must remain composed while weighing risk versus reward. Britney’s strategic mind and resilience make her an ideal competitor for this high-intensity game.
Final Thoughts: Which Traitor Will Face the Banker?
These four Traitors stars have what it takes to thrive on Deal or No Deal Island. Derrick Levasseur’s strategic genius, Gabby Windey’s social charm, Dylan Efron’s physical prowess, and Britney Haynes’ calculated gameplay all make them strong contenders.
Who would you love to see take on the Banker’s challenges? With the unpredictable nature of reality TV, we may just see one of these stars battling for millions on the next season of DONDI.
Deal or No Deal Island is streaming now on Peacock. Don’t miss the latest twists and turns!
- Who Is Greg Gutfeld’s Wife? Elena Moussa’s Job & Relationship History - April 4, 2025
- Kamala Harris’ Stepdaughter Ella Emhoff’s Paris Photos Focus On Mini Tennis Skirt - April 4, 2025
- Drake Net Worth - April 4, 2025
